Pleural Disease

Pleural Effusion

1. Pleural Effusion

1.1 Epidemiology

  • Pleural disease is common worldwide, affecting ~3000 people per million annually.
  • Pleural effusion (fluid in the pleural space) is among the most frequent pleural disorders.
  • Most effusions are either transudatesparapneumonic/infected effusions, or malignant effusions.

1.2 Aetiology

pleural effusion arises when fluid accumulates in the pleural space – underlying mechanisms differ between transudate and exudate:
  1. Transudate Effusions (often bilateral)
    • Usually due to systemic factors (e.g. increased hydrostatic pressure, decreased oncotic pressure)
    • Common causes:
      • Cardiac failure
      • Renal failure
      • Liver cirrhosis (hypoalbuminaemia)
      • Nephrotic syndrome
      • Hypothyroidism (rare)
  2. Exudate Effusions (usually unilateral)
    • Result from pleural disease or inflammation altering capillary permeability or lymphatic drainage
    • Common causes:
      • Infection (parapneumonic effusions, empyema, tuberculosis)
      • Malignancy (lung cancer, breast cancer, mesothelioma)
      • Pulmonary embolism
      • Rheumatoid arthritis or SLE (connective tissue disease)
      • Pancreatitis (high amylase effusions)

1.3 Risk Factors

  • Cardiac disease (heart failure, constrictive pericarditis)
  • Chronic liver disease (cirrhosis)
  • Chronic kidney disease (nephrotic syndrome, renal failure)
  • Infections (pneumonia, tuberculosis)
  • Malignancy (primary or metastatic)
  • Connective tissue diseases (e.g. rheumatoid arthritis, SLE)

1.4 Clinical Features

  • Breathlessness (dyspnoea) as fluid accumulates:
    • Rate of fluid build-up influences symptom severity.
  • Pleuritic chest pain may occur if the pleura are inflamed (e.g. parapneumonic effusion) or infiltrated by malignancy.
  • On examination:
    • Reduced chest expansion on the affected side
    • Stony dullness to percussion
    • Quiet or diminished breath sounds
    • Possible bronchial breathing above large effusions (where lung is compressed).

1.5 Diagnostic Approach

  1. Chest X-ray
    • Confirms presence of fluid (blunting of costophrenic angles, fluid level).
    • Large effusions appear as water-dense shadows with a meniscus sign.
  2. Blood Tests
    • Routine: FBC, U&E, LFTs.
    • Additional tests depending on clinical suspicion: e.g. tumour markers, rheumatoid factor, ANA, etc.
  3. Pleural Aspiration (Ultrasound-guided)
    • At least 50 mL of fluid taken for:
      • ProteinLDHglucosepH
      • Microbiological tests (culture, acid-fast bacilli if TB suspected)
      • Cytology (malignant cells)
    • Light’s criteria differentiate exudates from transudates.
  4. Further Imaging
    • Pleural ultrasound: detects loculations, guiding aspiration/drain placement.
    • CT thorax (especially if exudate): identifies pleural thickening, nodularity, or a suspicious lung lesion.
  5. Pleural Biopsy
    • Required if a cause remains unclear after fluid analysis (particularly if malignancy or tuberculosis is suspected).
    • Can be done via image-guided (US/CT) needle biopsy or thoracoscopy.

1.6 Immediate Management

  1. Symptomatic Relief
    • Drain large effusions if they cause significant breathlessness. Typically remove fluid slowly (0.5–1.5 L/24 h) to prevent re-expansion pulmonary oedema.
  2. Address Underlying Causes
    • Diuretics for fluid overload (cardiac/renal).
    • Antibiotics if infection is suspected.
    • Therapeutic aspiration may temporarily relieve symptoms while awaiting definitive diagnosis.

1.7 Long-Term Management

  • Treat the underlying disease: e.g. optimising heart failure, controlling liver disease, managing malignancy.
  • Recurrent Effusions (especially malignant):
    • Repeated aspirations for symptomatic relief.
    • Pleurodesis (e.g. talc insufflation) or pleurectomy to obliterate the pleural space and prevent fluid reaccumulation.

1.8 Prognosis / Complications

  • Prognosis depends heavily on the underlying cause.
  • Malignant effusions have poor outcomes as they indicate advanced disease.
  • Infective causes (e.g. empyema) need prompt drainage to avert complications like sepsis or persistent pleural thickening.
  • Uncontrolled effusions can severely reduce quality of life due to dyspnoea.
Pneumothorax

2.1 Epidemiology

  • Pneumothorax refers to air in the pleural space, causing partial or complete lung collapse.
  • Incidence of primary spontaneous pneumothorax is higher in males (about 2–3 times more common) and typically peaks in the early 20s.

2.2 Aetiology

Pneumothoraces are generally classified into:

  1. Primary Spontaneous Pneumothorax
    • Occurs without underlying lung disease.
    • Commonly in tall, thin, young men; risk increased by smoking or inhalation of recreational drugs.
    • Often due to subpleural blebs/bullae rupture.
    • Associations: Marfan’s syndrome, Ehlers–Danlos syndrome.
  2. Secondary Spontaneous Pneumothorax
    • Occurs with pre-existing lung disease (e.g. COPD, cystic fibrosis, advanced fibrotic conditions).
    • Even a small pneumothorax can be severe or life-threatening in patients with limited respiratory reserve.
  3. Tension Pneumothorax
    • Air enters the pleural space on inspiration but cannot escape on expiration.
    • Intrapleural pressure builds, compressing mediastinal structures.
    • Presents with hypotensiontracheal deviation away from the affected side, and severe respiratory distress.
    • Medical emergency (see below).
  4. Traumatic Pneumothorax
    • Caused by penetrating or blunt chest trauma, including iatrogenic injuries (e.g. central line placement, pleural biopsy).

2.3 Risk Factors

  • Smoking (major risk factor for subpleural blebs).
  • Underlying lung disease (COPD, cystic fibrosis, interstitial lung disease).
  • Connective tissue disorders (Marfan’s, Ehlers–Danlos).
  • Mechanical ventilation (high airway pressures).
  • Chest trauma (accidental or iatrogenic).

2.4 Clinical Features

  • Sudden onset of pleuritic chest pain and/or breathlessness.
  • Small pneumothoraces may be asymptomatic (especially in young, otherwise healthy individuals).
  • Severe dyspnoea if the patient has poor respiratory reserve (as in COPD).
  • Physical exam:
    • Reduced chest expansion on the affected side
    • Hyperresonance to percussion
    • Diminished or absent breath sounds
  • Tension pneumothorax: Hypotension, distended neck veins, tracheal deviation away from the pneumothorax.

2.5 Diagnostic Approach

  1. Clinical Suspicion
    • Differentiate from pulmonary embolism or acute severe asthma/COPD exacerbation.
  2. Chest X-ray
    • Demonstrates a visible pleural line with no lung markings peripheral to it.
    • Tension pneumothorax: mediastinal shift away from the affected side.
  3. Further Imaging
    • CT chest: Used if a small pneumothorax is suspected but not clearly visible, or to distinguish large bullae from pneumothorax.

2.6 Immediate Management

2.6.1 Tension Pneumothorax

  • Do not investigate – treat with immediate decompression using a large-bore needle (2nd intercostal space, mid-clavicular line) before obtaining a chest X-ray.
  • Follow with chest drain insertion.

2.6.2 Spontaneous Pneumothorax

  • Primary spontaneous (in otherwise healthy individuals):
    • Small and asymptomatic: often observed; may resolve spontaneously.
    • Larger or symptomatic: aspirate pleural air.
      • If aspiration fails, insert chest drain.
  • Secondary spontaneous (associated with lung disease):
    • More likely to require chest drain.
    • Even small pneumothoraces can cause severe compromise.

2.6.3 Traumatic Pneumothorax

  • Chest drain typically indicated, especially if large (i.e. >2cm) or symptomatic.
  • Manage associated injuries (rib fractures, vascular trauma).

2.7 Long-Term Management

  • Chest drain care:
    • Monitor for continuous air leak (bubbling in the drain).
    • Failure of lung re-expansion or persistent air leak > 5–7 days may require surgical intervention (e.g. pleurectomy, bullae resection).
  • Preventive measures for recurrent pneumothoraces:
    • Pleurodesis or pleurectomy in cases of repeated episodes (bilateral or same-side recurrence), or for individuals with high-risk occupations (pilots, divers).
    • Smoking cessation.

2.8 Prognosis / Complications

  • Recurrence rate after a first primary spontaneous pneumothorax can be up to 50%, usually within 2 years.
  • Recurrence is higher for secondary pneumothoraces.
  • Smoking strongly increases recurrence risk.
  • Tension pneumothorax is life-threatening without rapid decompression.

Benign Pleural Thickening

3. Benign Pleural Thickening

3.1 Epidemiology

  • Benign pleural thickening is common and frequently asymptomatic.
  • Often detected incidentally on clinical examination or imaging.

3.2 Aetiology

Benign pleural thickening typically arises from previous pleural injury or non-malignant inflammatory processes. Common causes include:
  1. Post-Infection
    • Previous empyema (often basolateral thickening ± calcification).
    • Post-tuberculosis (‘apical capping’, can become calcified).
    • Chronic or persistent infection (e.g. non-tuberculous mycobacteria, aspergillosis).
  2. Inflammatory/Other Causes
    • Asbestos exposure (plaques ± diffuse pleural thickening).
    • Post-pleurodesis (deliberate induction of pleural adhesions).
    • Post-haemothorax (often basolateral thickening ± calcification).
    • Certain drugs (e.g. methysergide, bromocriptine) can cause diffuse changes.
  3. Benign after Trauma or Surgical Intervention
    • Scarring from chest trauma or interventional procedures.

3.3 Clinical Features

  • Generally asymptomatic and discovered incidentally.
  • On clinical examination:
    • Dullness to percussion
    • Quiet or diminished breath sounds over the thickened area
  • On imaging (e.g. chest X-ray):
    • Areas of pleural opacity; can be localised or diffuse
    • Possible calcification (especially post-infective or after haemothorax)
  • In extensive cases:
    • Restrictive lung defect on pulmonary function testing
    • Dyspnoea if large pleural areas are thickened

3.4 Diagnostic Approach

  1. Clinical History
    • Previous infections (tuberculosis, empyema), trauma, asbestos exposure.
  2. Imaging
    • Chest X-ray: May show plaques, calcification, or thickened pleura (basal or apical).
    • CT scan: Better characterises the extent of thickening, possible calcifications, and differentiates from malignancy.
    • Features suspicious for malignancy (e.g. mesothelioma) include nodular or circumferential thickening and mediastinal pleural involvement.
  3. Exclusion of Pleural Malignancy
    • If there is progressive thickening, nodularity, or involvement of the mediastinal pleura, further investigations (biopsy) may be required.

3.5 Management

  • Typically no active intervention is required if the patient is asymptomatic and imaging suggests stable benign thickening.
  • Surgical pleurectomy (removal of pleura) is considered only in severe cases where extensive pleural thickening causes debilitating restrictive defects and dyspnoea.
    • This procedure carries significant morbidity and mortality.

3.6 Prognosis / Complications

  • Usually stable and does not progress if the inciting cause is removed or resolved (e.g. treated infection, avoidance of asbestos).
  • Differential diagnosis: Pleural malignancy (e.g. mesothelioma) can mimic benign thickening. Ongoing monitoring or investigation may be necessary if there is any suspicion of malignancy.

Written by Dr Ahmed Kazie MD, MSc
  • References
    1. Laura-Jane Smith, Brown JS, Quint J. Respiratory medicine. London ; Philadelphia: Jp Medical Publishers; 2015.
    2. Sattar HA. Fundamentals of pathology : medical course and step 1 review. Chicago, Illinois: Pathoma.com; 2024.
    3. Wilkinson I, Raine T, Wiles K, Hateley P, Kelly D, McGurgan I. OXFORD HANDBOOK OF CLINICAL MEDICINE International Edition. 11th ed. Oxford University Press; 2024.
    4. Lee GM, Walker CM. Pleural Thickening: Detection, Characterization, and Differential Diagnosis. Seminars in roentgenology [Internet]. 2023 Oct 1 [cited 2025 Feb 21];58(4):399–410. Available from: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0037198X23000378#:~:text=Benign%20pleural%20thickening%20caused%20by,apical%20cap%20and%20pleural%20plaque.

Last Updated: February 2025